Unholy Conversations ·

Philosophy under fire: Quassim Cassam on Hamas, genocide claims and the open letter against him

Philosopher Quassim Cassam on why peace with Hamas is fanciful, what genocide actually means, and the open letter from his own department condemning him.

Quassim Cassam, Professor of philosophy at the University of Warwick, co-author with Richard English of How to Think About Terrorism, in conversation with Yonit Levi and Jonathan Freedland. 9 min read.

Philosophy Under Fire: Quassim Cassam on Gaza, Genocide Claims, and the Open Letter Against Him

Quassim Cassam is professor of philosophy at the University of Warwick and the co-author, with the politics scholar Richard English, of How to Think About Terrorism. He is also, as Jonathan Freedland disclosed at the top of this Tuesday's Unholy Conversations, the man who taught him philosophy at university several decades ago.

Cassam has spent the past year at the centre of a fierce dispute. A paper he wrote arguing that a negotiated peace with Hamas is not possible drew a sharp reply from the philosopher of war Jeff McMahan, then a response from Cassam, and then an open letter from teaching assistants in his own department condemning him. Yonit Levi and Jonathan asked him to walk through the argument, the backlash, and what he thinks the debate about Gaza gets wrong. This is the conversation, in his own words where it matters.

From the son of a Marxist to 7 October

Cassam is an Ismaili Muslim born in Kenya. His father, a Marxist dentist, brought him up as a little Marxist too, and that came with being pro-Palestinian and anti-Israeli. As a boy in the 1970s he cheered the Arab side's early successes in the 1973 war and thought the PLO were the good guys. Looking back, he said, none of it was based on any knowledge. It was tribal.

"if your dad is an Arsenal fan, you kind of just grow up to be an Arsenal fan."

His views changed dramatically once he began working on terrorism and extremism, and 7 October, he said, was a transformational moment.

Why negotiation cannot work with Hamas

The paper that started the row asked a simple question. Jonathan Powell, now the UK's national security adviser, argued in his 2014 book Talking to Terrorists that it is always right to negotiate with terrorists, even if it is not always the right time, and his model was Britain's negotiation with the IRA. Why, Cassam asked, would that model not apply to Israel and Hamas?

He set out five conditions for a negotiated peace: each side must be willing and authorised to negotiate, each must recognise the other as a legitimate interlocutor, there must be some mutual trust, there must be a willingness to compromise, and there must be some possibility of third-party enforcement. Hamas, he argued, fails the most basic of them. Its ideology is one of no compromise, and its covenant rejects peace conferences in favour of jihad. The IRA did compromise. And the IRA never questioned the United Kingdom's right to exist, just as Algeria's FLN never campaigned for the non-existence of France. Hamas wants the obliteration of Israel.

"Negotiating over what? Well, they want you to die. They want you not to exist."

The IRA, he said, is a fantastic comparator precisely because comparing the two cases shows how different they are, and why Powell's optimism does not carry over.

Terrorism and horrorism

Yonit asked what puts Hamas beyond the pale, as Cassam puts it in the essay. He reached for a concept from the Italian philosopher Adriana Cavarero, who described "horrorism" twenty years ago as violence that goes beyond death itself.

"the horrorist isn't merely content to kill because they think that killing would be too little."

ISIS's beheadings are the classic case. What is striking about Hamas on 7 October, he said, is the mutilation and the gross, repellent sexual violence. Even if the perpetrators had not been ordered to do it, that conduct would place them beyond the pale, and he believes there is a lot of evidence they were encouraged to as a tactic.

"October the 7th in and of itself placed it beyond the pale of dialogue and negotiation in my view."

Degrade and destroy

If negotiation is off the table, what is left? Cassam pointed to Barack Obama's statement in 2014 that the American mission was to degrade and ultimately destroy ISIL. Nobody, he said, batted an eyelid.

"I don't see actually what the moral difference is between degrading and destroying Hamas and degrading and destroying ISIL"

That raises hard questions about Gaza's civilians, he acknowledged, but as a framing of the objective he wants to know why progressives who accepted it for ISIS object to it here. His answer is that people have convinced themselves Hamas is not as bad as ISIS, which he called plainly wrong.

The exchange with Jeff McMahan

The journal that invited his paper, Cassam said, deserves credit for publishing it despite the editor's pushback. What it also did, without telling him, was share his draft with McMahan and publish McMahan's reply alongside it. Cassam called McMahan a distinguished and serious philosopher whose work he has cited and against whom he has no personal animus. But he summarised the central claim of the reply as this: everything horrendous Hamas has done, Israel has also done, usually to a much greater extent.

"Now when I read that sentence, I almost fell out of my chair."

He wrote a response, which the journal accepted with some changes, and he has no idea whether the exchange will continue.

"I actually just reread those two papers of mine this morning. And I have to say, I stand by my arguments."

Empathy as a philosopher's tool

Jonathan picked out a line from Cassam's response: what is missing from McMahan's discussion is any attempt to understand what it was like to be an Israeli on and after 7 October. Philosophy is often imagined as bloodless reasoning, so why demand empathy?

Because, Cassam said, you cannot understand other human beings without trying to see the world through their eyes, even people you find repellent. He applies that to terrorists too: it matters to try to get inside Yahya Sinwar's head and work out why he ordered the attack the way he did.

"empathy is part of the project of human understanding."

He was in London on 7 July 2005 and still remembers it as an unreal day. Imagine, he said, living in a country where that happened regularly, as in the second intifada, and then waking up on 7 October to the possibility of the country being overrun. Seen that way, much of Israeli politics starts to make sense. What he found missing in McMahan's work, and in progressive responses generally, was any willingness to set aside the arguments about one state and two states and look at it as something happening in real time to innocent people, many of them sympathetic to the Palestinian cause.

"not just failure of imagination, almost the policy of not trying to imagine what that felt like"

The imaginative effort, he noted, is lavished on Palestinian suffering, and many Israelis share it. He has Israeli and Jewish friends in agony about the war's impact on Palestinian civilians. The demand runs both ways.

"each side has got to be willing to see the world through the other side's eyes and to feel, in some sense, feel the other side's pain. If you can't do that, you have no hope of really understanding what's going on. And it also shows that you lack a certain kind of humanity."

That, he said, is a moral point as much as a philosophical one.

The open letter

Yonit turned to what happened next. Three teaching assistants in Cassam's department wrote an open letter condemning him, circulated it to his colleagues asking them to sign, and have threatened to publish it. He said he had been expecting something like it for two or three years.

"So it's a letter that's impugning my moral character as well as my academic judgement."

He called it a campaign of intimidation by people who are his colleagues, not just students, and asked how any other workplace would react if staff circulated a petition denouncing a co-worker as a wicked person. What strikes him most is the content.

"the thing that's so striking about the open letter is that it doesn't actually engage with any of my arguments."

The university, he said, is still considering how to respond.

Why Israel is singled out

Jonathan linked the letter to an aside in one of Cassam's papers: international opinion cared little about civilian deaths when Sri Lanka crushed the Tamil Tigers, but cares a great deal about civilian deaths in Gaza. Does that tell us something about the next generation of elites?

"I think what it reveals is that there's a kind of perception of Israel as somehow uniquely evil, uniquely diabolical."

He cited Simon Sebag Montefiore's The Cauldron, a history of the Middle East since 1900 that he has just read, with its accounts of massacres and genocides, some very recent: Iran's killing of protesters this year, Darfur, Assad's Syria. Where, he asked the young, were you when those were happening? One explanation for the singling out may be that Israel is a Jewish state. But he thinks it is more than that. Drawing on René Girard's theory of the scapegoat, he argued that Israel has become a symbol onto which the West projects what it sees as its own historic sins: colonialism, genocide, apartheid and whiteness.

"I want you to tell me why you focus on this one case to the exclusion of the others."

What genocide actually means

Yonit asked whether the way the word genocide is thrown around reflects a breakdown of moral or philosophical values. Both, Cassam said. He wonders how many people who accuse Israel of genocide know how it is defined. The usual answer is a death toll, but by that measure, he said, almost every war since the Second World War would qualify. Genocide means acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group as such.

"it's not enough to be genocide that you kill a hundred Irish people and they're all Irish, you've got to be killing them because they're Irish."

Intent is the hard part to prove, and the evidence usually offered is statements by far-right Israeli extremists who are not the government and were not running the IDF in Gaza. He says in the article that he is not foreclosing the question.

"if you're going to accuse anyone of genocide, you need to produce evidence of genocidal intent."

With Hamas, he argued, that evidence exists, in repeated statements from its covenant to the present day.

Proportionality is not arithmetic

Proportionality gets the same treatment in his lectures. If someone kills a thousand of your civilians, is it proportional to kill a thousand of theirs? Most students sense that is wrong. Even McMahan's definition, that the bad effects of war must not be excessive in relation to its good effects, leaves everything to judgement about what counts as excessive, bad and good.

"proportionality is not a mathematical concept."

What worries him most is the unseriousness of the debate among people who are highly educated and ought to know better, graduate students in philosophy among them, whose job is serious analytical thought about complex questions.

"Well, we do have to get into the ins and outs of all this."

Jonathan closed by saying that hearing his old tutor say "it's not good enough" gave him flashbacks to reading essays aloud across the desk, and that he left this conversation, like those tutorials, with twenty more questions.

Cassam's essay Beyond the Pale is available here. The full episode is on YouTube, Apple Podcasts and Spotify.

Listen to the full conversation

Philosophy Under Fire: Quassim Cassam on Gaza, Genocide Claims, and the Open Letter Against Him. Free wherever you get your podcasts, and on video on YouTube.

Bonus episodes for members on YouTube, Patreon and Apple Podcasts.

Topics: Quassim Cassam · Philosophy · Hamas · October 7 · Gaza war · Genocide · Proportionality · Jeff McMahan · Terrorism · University of Warwick · Academic freedom · Yonit Levi · Jonathan Freedland

All posts →

Unholy Conversations ·

Israel's Arab kingmakers: Nagham Zbeedat on the vote, the boycott she ended, and what comes next

A week after Israel voted, the political map is still unclear, and one fact sits at the centre of every coalition calculation: Arab turnout was massive, and the Arab-led parties now hold 19 seats in the Knesset. For this Tuesday's Unholy Conversations, Yonit Levi and Jonathan Freedland asked Nagham Zbeedat what that means. She covers Palestinian affairs and the Arab world for Haaretz, her hometown is Sakhnin in the north, and she joined from Haifa.

With Nagham Zbeedat · 10 min read

Unholy ·

Five days out: what to watch on Israel's election night

Israel votes on Tuesday 27 October. For once, Yonit Levi and Jonathan Freedland recorded in the same room: Jonathan flew into Tel Aviv for the final stretch, and the two of them spent the episode on what will actually decide the night, what Netanyahu is doing in the closing days, and what Jonathan saw at a Gadi Eisenkot rally in Modi'in the evening before. Unholy goes live on YouTube at 21:55 Israel time on election night, five minutes before the exit poll, with Jonathan, Ruth Margalit, Matti Friedman and Anshel Pfeffer. Yonit will be anchoring Channel 12's coverage.

Yonit Levi and Jonathan Freedland · 9 min read

Unholy Conversations ·

The word that blew up Israel's election, and the divide behind it

A week before Israel votes on 27 October, Yinon Magal, the Channel 14 presenter who is among Benjamin Netanyahu's most loyal media allies, called Gadi Eisenkot a monkey on his Saturday night show. He said it three times, with the claim that Ashkenazi elites were pulling the strings. Eisenkot, the former chief of staff running to replace Netanyahu, has Moroccan roots.

With Matti Friedman · 8 min read