Unholy Conversations ·

Israel's Arab kingmakers: Nagham Zbeedat on the vote, the boycott she ended, and what comes next

Haaretz's Nagham Zbeedat on the record Arab turnout, the boycott she ended on election day, and whether Ra'am and the Joint List can back a change government.

Nagham Zbeedat, Haaretz correspondent covering Palestinian affairs and the Arab world, from Sakhnin, reporting from Haifa, in conversation with Yonit Levi and Jonathan Freedland. 10 min read.

Israel's Arab kingmakers - with Nagham Zbeedat

A week after Israel voted, the political map is still unclear, and one fact sits at the centre of every coalition calculation: Arab turnout was massive, and the Arab-led parties now hold 19 seats in the Knesset. For this Tuesday's Unholy Conversations, Yonit Levi and Jonathan Freedland asked Nagham Zbeedat what that means. She covers Palestinian affairs and the Arab world for Haaretz, her hometown is Sakhnin in the north, and she joined from Haifa.

She also brought a story of her own. Zbeedat had boycotted Knesset elections for years and went into election day still intending to. By the end of it she had voted. This is the conversation, in her own words where it matters, with timecodes for the full episode above.

Not excitement. A very sober pride

Jonathan's opening question was whether the record turnout had produced excitement, energy, even pride. Zbeedat chose her words carefully.

"I would say it's a mix a mixture of satisfaction, belief, deep apprehension, but also anger following the fraud investigation campaign led by the Netanyahu government."

The turnout, she argued, was not a vote of confidence in Israel's political system. It was driven by urgency, fear and anger, and for many people the aim was simply to remove Benjamin Netanyahu, Itamar Ben-Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich after years of war and escalating violence in the Arab community. In her reporting she met people who had boycotted the Knesset for years and voted this time for exactly that reason.

"so the pride in the turnout is existent, but I would say it's a very kind, very sober pride."

People are now asking, she said, what this participation can actually achieve.

Two parties, two approaches, both rewarded

Yonit asked how Ra'am and the Joint List differ in how they want to use that power. Zbeedat drew the line through identity. Ra'am's main goal is civil issues, home demolitions, limited budgets, violence in the Arab community, and it is willing to sit in government. The Joint List, Hadash-Ta'al and Balad, works on the same issues but frames them under the national identity of Palestinian citizens of Israel, connected to Palestinians in Gaza, the West Bank and the diaspora, and will support a government only from the opposition.

Jonathan's puzzle was that both approaches grew massively. Nobody chose one path over the other. Zbeedat's answer was that the turnout had no single explanation. People voted out of fear and a sense of neglect, over restrictions on speaking Arabic at work, over home demolitions from the north to the Negev, over gun violence in Arab towns.

"whether it's Ra'am or the joint list, people just wanted to vote remove the Netanyahu government."

The fraud claims, and the day she ended her boycott

Yonit raised Netanyahu's claims that the Arab vote was rigged and subject to foreign interference, and the racist comments from some of his supporters. Zbeedat described the reaction as anger and annoyance at being asked, election after election, to come out and remove Netanyahu, then being labelled a fraud for doing it. For her it was personal. She felt humiliated, she said, precisely because of where she had been standing.

"I myself was boycotting the Israeli Knesset, the Israeli election for years now and I did struggle with making my decision this time whether I should vote or abstain"

Jonathan had read what she wrote about that day and asked what finally pushed her over the line. She was covering Arab towns for Haaretz on election day, Sakhnin among them, where her own ballot was waiting, and she kept putting the visit off because she had not decided. That morning she was determined to keep boycotting.

"I spoke on that day I spoke to so many people who used to boycott the election. I spoke to so many people who have been participating in the election for decades. And I think each person I interviewed that day had a little bit of influence on making my decision."

"at the end of that day I made peace with my decision thinking that maybe maybe at least with my vote one family, one Palestinian family, whether it is in Gaza, the West Bank or in Israel, could go home to bed believing that tomorrow will be better."

Why she boycotted in the first place

Her father always votes, and the two of them argue about it. The boycott, she said, was a principle built from history and from the people she has interviewed. The Knesset election is presented as a democratic tool for all citizens to express their voice and aim for change. For Palestinian citizens, she thinks that is only partly true.

"we are constantly treated as less than citizens, as not equal whether it's citizens, whether it's Arab representatives in the Knesset."

Her evidence is the Nation-State Law, which gives national identity exclusively to Jewish people. Arab representatives have sat in the Knesset since the founding of the state, and the law passed anyway, at a moment when the Arab parties held 15 seats, were the third largest bloc, and there was even an Arab party in the coalition.

"So I don't think that participation is the issue but rather the political limitation that are given to the Arab representatives in the Knesset that are the issues for me."

Eisenkot's fourth condition

Jonathan asked how determined the Arab-led parties now are to form a government of change, and whether they would cross old red lines to do it. Zbeedat split the question in two. The opposition that may be led by Gadi Eisenkot does not look as determined to sit with the Arab parties, given the conditions and hesitations it has expressed. And the Arab voters' strong desire for change does not amount to an unconditional mandate: supporting a government that promises funding is one thing, supporting one that passes laws like the Nation-State Law is another.

Yonit laid out the hypocrisy in the system. In 2021 Netanyahu met Mansour Abbas four times and tried to get Smotrich to agree to Ra'am joining his coalition. On the other side, the Joint List cooperated with Likud to vote down bills and help bring down the change government. Then she put Eisenkot's fourth condition to Zbeedat: anyone joining his coalition must call Hamas a terror organisation and call for its destruction. Would Abbas go that extra mile?

"Even that statement I would break it into two different parts because stating that Hamas is a terrorist organization is a one thing and then aim it and then calling for its destruction is another thing"

Her reason is what Haaretz and other Israeli outlets have reported about the human death toll when Hamas members were targeted.

"I think the distinction between the destruction of Hamas and the destruction of Gaza is a very thin line"

Even so, her prediction was clear. Abbas has pursued pragmatic engagement with the Israeli state and has recognised Israel as a Jewish state in the past.

"So I think Mansour Abbas of all will be willing to go the extra mile."

She called him a very smart, well spoken politician and said she is eager to see his next move. Jonathan agreed: Abbas has been a guest on Unholy, and most people expect him to find a way over the hurdles.

How far can the Joint List go?

The Joint List is a different matter. Its factions have historically opposed defining Israel as a Jewish state, which they see as incompatible with equal national and civil rights for Palestinian citizens, and part of their vote this time came precisely because of that Palestinian national identification. On recognising Israel as a Jewish state, and on condemning and calling for the destruction of Hamas, Zbeedat said she would be cautious and not optimistic about them going the extra mile.

Yonit raised the disqualification of Balad's leader, Sami Abu Shehadeh, over what he wrote after 7 October, and asked whether Zbeedat could understand the trepidation some Jewish voters feel.

"I would understand why some people, some Jewish Israeli people, would be hesitant for this cooperation between the opposition and the the Arab parties"

But that hesitation, she went on, looks at one group's struggle and ignores the other's entirely. Abu Shehadeh apologised for his article, she said his disqualification was unjust, and Knesset members have said worse and are still there.

As long as that hesitation stands, she expects the separation between Jewish and Arab Israelis to stand with it, which she finds strange, because the two sides want the same thing.

"we're fighting for the same thing"

Democracy and justice, she said. If one side overlooks the other's democracy because it only cares how that democracy might affect it, everyone stays stuck in the same loop, whatever government is formed.

Would it survive a war?

Jonathan's stress test: imagine a change government with Ra'am inside and the Joint List supporting from outside. Then Israel resumes military action against Iran, or steps up operations in Gaza or the West Bank. Could either party stay?

Zbeedat called it one of the hardest questions for any prospective coalition. The 2021 experience showed an Arab party can sit in an Israeli government, but that government was already fragile when the Gaza war of 2021 came and exposed the limits of political cohesion. A confrontation with Iran would be framed by much of the Israeli system as a matter of national security and existence. For Palestinian citizens the question is more complicated, and in Gaza they would be asked to support military action against their own people, to whom many have political, historical and ideological connections.

"Even if they don't support the Hamas government, even if they don't support the Iranian regime and policies, I think it is entirely possible that the Arab parties could support a government on a domestic issues while opposing a particular military operation and participation."

Whether they could remain in the government, she said, would depend on the scale of the operation.

Citizens first

Yonit asked for a glimmer of optimism: what do Jews and Arabs need to understand about each other so that in five years the three of them could sit down and say things got better? Zbeedat's answer was compromise on both sides, because so far it has been demanded of Palestinians alone.

"I have and I must look at why might Jewish Israelis be afraid and hesitant to sit with Palestinians and Arab representatives in the Knesset and why they don't have faith for in in the Arab representatives to speak about their problems."

The same effort, she said, has to come from the Jewish Israeli side. Over the years, Palestinians and Arabs have been asked to vote, and asked to remove the Netanyahu government.

"But when they demand security, safety, inclusion, equality, their demands are negotiable and their citizenship is always on a test"

Their loyalty too, she added.

"So I think accepting Palestinians and Arabs as citizens first is a good start to begin with."

Jonathan's last question was whether a genuine mass party that Jews and Arabs vote for together is conceivable, or naive. Too early, she said. Standing Together's Makom LeKulanu, A Place for All of Us, embodied exactly that intention and included both Jewish and Arab voices, but it did not get the support it expected and withdrew from the race. There may be another run. There is a lot of work to do in Israel first.

What the hosts took from it

After the interview, Jonathan returned to her journey from boycott to ballot, the kitchen-table argument with her father, and the neglected issue of crime in the Arab sector. The question now, he said, is whether the turnout eventuates in a new government. Yonit picked out the honesty of Zbeedat saying she understands why some Israeli Jews are afraid of this cooperation, an ability to see the other that may be lacking in Israeli society generally. She recalled Ayman Odeh, newly leader of the Joint List in 2015, sitting in her studio with Aryeh Deri of Shas and telling him that two discriminated-against communities could cooperate. It never really happened, but the lines are there.

Jonathan ended with a warning. It is now clear there will be no anti-Netanyahu government without this support.

"If this opportunity is lost, I do worry, based on what she was saying, that a lot of people in the community of Palestinian Israeli citizens will just conclude, well, look, it w we did we did our bit, it led to nothing, and we're gonna walk away."

The full episode is on YouTube, Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Unholy is back with a regular episode on Thursday, including the US midterms.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Nineteen seats and an unclear map
  2. 01:05The mood after record turnout: a very sober pride
  3. 03:37Ra'am and the Joint List: two approaches, both rewarded
  4. 07:04Fraud claims, humiliation, and the day she ended her boycott
  5. 10:44Arguing with her father, and the Nation-State Law
  6. 13:40Eisenkot's fourth condition and Mansour Abbas
  7. 19:10How far can the Joint List go? Sami Abu Shehadeh and Jewish fears
  8. 24:22Would such a government survive a war with Iran or Gaza?
  9. 27:51Citizens first: what has to change on both sides
  10. 30:06A shared Jewish-Arab party, and Standing Together
  11. 32:06Yonit and Jonathan's closing reflection

Listen to the full conversation

Israel's Arab kingmakers - with Nagham Zbeedat. Free wherever you get your podcasts, and on video on YouTube.

Bonus episodes for members on YouTube, Patreon and Apple Podcasts.

Topics: Nagham Zbeedat · Israel election 2026 · Arab citizens of Israel · Palestinian citizens of Israel · Ra'am · Mansour Abbas · Joint List · Gadi Eisenkot · Benjamin Netanyahu · Nation-State Law · Sami Abu Shehadeh · Standing Together · Haaretz · Yonit Levi · Jonathan Freedland

All posts →

Unholy Conversations ·

Philosophy under fire: Quassim Cassam on Hamas, genocide claims and the open letter against him

Quassim Cassam is professor of philosophy at the University of Warwick and the co-author, with the politics scholar Richard English, of How to Think About Terrorism. He is also, as Jonathan Freedland disclosed at the top of this Tuesday's Unholy Conversations, the man who taught him philosophy at university several decades ago.

With Quassim Cassam · 9 min read

Unholy ·

Five days out: what to watch on Israel's election night

Israel votes on Tuesday 27 October. For once, Yonit Levi and Jonathan Freedland recorded in the same room: Jonathan flew into Tel Aviv for the final stretch, and the two of them spent the episode on what will actually decide the night, what Netanyahu is doing in the closing days, and what Jonathan saw at a Gadi Eisenkot rally in Modi'in the evening before. Unholy goes live on YouTube at 21:55 Israel time on election night, five minutes before the exit poll, with Jonathan, Ruth Margalit, Matti Friedman and Anshel Pfeffer. Yonit will be anchoring Channel 12's coverage.

Yonit Levi and Jonathan Freedland · 9 min read

Unholy Conversations ·

The word that blew up Israel's election, and the divide behind it

A week before Israel votes on 27 October, Yinon Magal, the Channel 14 presenter who is among Benjamin Netanyahu's most loyal media allies, called Gadi Eisenkot a monkey on his Saturday night show. He said it three times, with the claim that Ashkenazi elites were pulling the strings. Eisenkot, the former chief of staff running to replace Netanyahu, has Moroccan roots.

With Matti Friedman · 8 min read